Choose the Original!
Taste the best!
MENU
Fresh Ingredients. Legendary Flavors.
Every pie starts with dough mixed fresh daily, topped with our signature sauce and finished with cold, creamy provolone. Whether you’re picking up a full tray or ordering a slice, you’ll taste why DiCarlo’s has been Wheeling’s favorite pizza since 1949.
Order Online.
Ready When You Are.
Skip the line and get DiCarlo’s Pizza delivered straight to your door — or swing by and pick it up fresh from the oven. Online ordering is quick, easy, and available now.
About Us
The Story Behind Every Slice
The DiCarlo family’s culinary story began with a bakery, in the early 1900’s. During his service in Italy in World War II, Primo DiCarlo, the oldest member of the family, became captivated by a simple dish made with dough, tomatoes, and cheese. This inspiration led to the creation of Original DiCarlo’s Famous Pizza, which was officially established in 1945, Steubenville, Ohio.
