Downtown Wheeling
Hours:
Monday – Thursday: 11 AM – 9 PM
Friday – Saturday: 11 AM – 10 PM
Sunday: 11 AM – 9 PM
Original DiCarlo’s Pizza
Downtown Wheeling
Main Street’s Favorite Slice Since 1949
You’ll find Original DiCarlo’s Famous Pizza right in the heart of Downtown Wheeling, West Virginia, at 1311 Main St. Whether you’re grabbing lunch on your break, loading up before a show at WesBanco Arena, or making it a family tradition after a stroll along Heritage Port — this is where Wheeling comes for the real thing.
The Original Recipe. Right Here on Main Street.
Our Downtown Wheeling location has been serving the Ohio Valley’s most iconic square pizza for decades. Every pie starts with dough mixed fresh daily, topped with our signature tomato sauce, flash-baked in the oven, and finished with cold, 100% creamy provolone cheese. No frozen shortcuts. No MSG. No fillers. Just the original DiCarlo’s process — perfected over generations and served fresh on Main Street every day of the week.
Nearby Landmarks
We’re steps from WesBanco Arena and Heritage Port — making us the go-to stop before concerts, Nailers games, and Wheeling Island events. Heading down Main Street? Pull in, grab a tray, and taste what nearly 75 years of tradition feels like.